ReviewsUMPC

Review: UMID mbook BZ

Umid_bz_review

Originally known as the UMID M2 but officially rechristened the UMID mbook BZ, the Atom-based clamshell MID/UMPC was launched at CES 2010 and is now available at Dynamism. It is the successor to last year's mbook M1, which received mixed reviews due to early build quality issues and hardware quirks like a less-than-ideal screen angle, non-standard ports that required unwieldy adapters to use, and no pointing device.

UMID took its customers' complaints seriously and released the BZ with an updated high-quality casing that included an improved screen angle, standard ports, an optical mouse with mouse buttons, and some additional niceties. The base model's specs were not upgraded, though, so hardware would really be the main incentive for anyone to consider the BZ.

Is it enough to warrant a new purchase? Read my full review to find out.

System Specifications (as reviewed)

CPU:
1.2GHz Intel Atom Z515
RAM: 512MB DDR2
OS: Windows XP Home
Storage: 32GB SSD*
Display: 4.8" resistive touchscreen (1024 x 600)
Wireless: 802.11b/g, Bluetooth 2.0 + EDR
Size: 6.33" x 3.79" x 0.75"
Weight: 12.8 oz

*The BZ currently shipping from Dynamism has a 16GB SSD.

See my UMID mbook BZ unboxing for some of the available accessories, both included and optional.

Design

Like the black mbook M1 (but unlike the other colors), the mbook BZ has a matte exterior finish that seems fairly resistant to scratches.

Umid_bz_des1

The screen and keyboard bezels are composed of smooth silver plastic that carries some sheen but is not glossy. The entire unit masks fingerprints and other smudges very well, ensuring that the BZ is always in presentable, non-greasy condition.

Umid_bz_des2

The device itself is attractive from the outside—round corners, soft ridges, silver accents, and smooth sides with no unsightly bulges or protrusions—but may be more of an acquired taste on the inside because of the lack of symmetry on the screen bezel, which is already quite thick on the left and right sides. There's something a little messy-looking about the placement of the elements on the bezel, which appear more pronounced because of the contrasting colors (black on silver). An all-black unit like the black M1 would've looked better, in my opinion, but I think the BZ would still turn heads as it is.

Umid_bz_ports 

Umid_bz_microsd

Build Quality

While the original M1 suffered from quality issues that were eventually sorted out shortly after launch, the BZ is coming out of the gate with high quality materials that have been put together very well. The device is sturdy, with no cosmetic imperfections or evidence of shoddy construction.

Umid_bz_bottom

There's some creaking and flexing on the back panel if deliberately/forcefully pressed, but everything else feels incredibly solid and strong.

Size

Umid_bz_soda 

Umid_bz_size

The UMID BZ isn't the smallest Atom-based clamshell MID on the market (that title belongs to its sibling, the M1), but it's compact, portable, and yes, even pocketable. It's easy to become jaded by all the gadgets that are available to us these days, but when you really stop and consider how small full-blown computers have become in a matter of years, it's truly amazing.

Umid_bz_vaiop 

Umid_bz_clamshells

Umid_bz_shift 

Umid_bz_d4 

Umid_bz_comp 

Umid_bz_phones

You can see more size comparisons in my BZ unboxing post.

Display

Like its predecessor and a handful of other current MIDs, the UMID mbook BZ has a 4.8-inch resistive touchscreen with a resolution of 1024 x 600. The display is crisp and bright from all natural viewing angles, and the touchscreen layer does not adversely affect clarity, even against white backgrounds.

Umid_bz_hinge

The display hinge is very strong and tight; it holds the screen securely in any position. It's so sturdy, in fact, that you can actually hold the entire unit by the screen in any angle and it will stay that way, even if you flip the device upside down and right-side up again.

Touchscreen

One of the reasons the UMID M1 was so usable without any kind of pointing device is that it had an excellent touchscreen. Responsiveness and accuracy were so good that many could maneuver through Windows XP, an operating system not known for its finger-friendliness, with relative ease. Even small targets were simple to hit with a soft tap of a stylus or fingernail.

Fortunately, the same holds true for the UMID BZ. Even though it does have an optical mouse and mouse buttons, the touchscreen is so good and responsive that it's often quicker to tap the screen than use the hardware controls.

Screen Angle

Umid_bz_screen_angle

Unlike the M1, the BZ's screen can be pushed back to an angle that is comfortable and optimal for both handheld and tabletop use.

Controls

In addition to the touchscreen (discussed above) and the keyboard (discussed below), the UMID BZ is equipped with hardware controls for navigation.

Optical Mouse & Mouse Buttons

Flanking the display are a recessed optical mouse on the right and small rubberized mouse buttons on the left. Neither is implemented exceptionally well, but both are functional and easy enough to use. The strength of the screen hinge, detailed above, prevents the display from budging under the pressure of your thumbs, so you don't have to worry about having to constantly reset your desired screen angle.

Umid_bz_mouse 

The optical mouse is sensitive and the movement on screen is smooth, but it would be better if the optical pad wasn't sunken in so the thumb could glide over the entire area more comfortably and freely.

Umid_bz_mousebuttons

The mouse buttons have a nice clicky sound/feel to them, but they're a little small for my taste. If I put my thumb over both of them, it can't immediately distinguish the separation; that is, if my thumb didn't know any better, it would think a single button was resting beneath it. I actually don't position my thumb like that so I don't have trouble using the mouse buttons, but it's worth mentioning.

I like that an optical mouse and mouse buttons are included on the UMID BZ, but I don't really care for their placement. I would rather have seen them on the keyboard-half of the device like on the Sharp NetWalker to minimize switching hand positions. I suppose it depends on the size of your hands and fingers, but I personally can't thumb type on the keyboard and reach the mouse controls without moving my hands.

The screen-half of the BZ is also top-heavy, which you tend to notice when switching from holding the device by the keyboard to holding it more in the middle. The weight is nicely distributed in the latter position, so the unit feels more balanced if you're consuming content (when you're more likely to just use the mouse controls) rather than creating it.

Cap Sensor

Above the keyboard is a capacitive strip that UMID calls the Cap Sensor.

Umid_bz_cap1 

Umid_bz_cap2

Pressing the Fn key while sliding your finger across the sensor brings up a menu that lets you adjust screen brightness, volume, zoom, scrolling, and resolution, as well as access two user-defined quick menu buttons and lock/unlock the sensor.

Though placed in an area that not all thumbs could easily reach, the Cap Sensor is still a nice feature.

Wireless Button

On the UMID M1, the WiFi and Bluetooth radios were "connected" so that both had to be either on or off. On the BZ, the radios can be controlled separately.

Umid_bz_wirelessbutton 

Umid_bz_wireless

Pressing the wireless button next to the power button launches a simple menu with WiFi and Bluetooth icons. Tapping or clicking on the icons toggles them on (blue) or off (black).

Keyboard

In my UMID M1 review, I praised the device's 56-key keyboard for its ability to be used

"with equal comfort for thumb typing when held between both hands and multi-finger typing when used on a flat surface. Both usage scenarios are possible with other devices, of course, but one use is inevitably always better than the other because of the device's size, design, etc. With the UMID, however, users come closer than ever before to having the best of both worlds. I don't think the mbook offers the best single-use experience, as the OQO Model 02 has a better thumboard and something like the Everun Note has a better hunt-and-peck/touch-typable keyboard, but nothing on the market is better for both uses."

I still believe this to be true with the UMID BZ. It doesn't provide the single best thumb or multi-finger typing experience on a mobile device, but it's very good for both purposes. The keys press down evenly, offer good tactile feedback, and have a nice feel to them.

Umid_bz_kb1 

Umid_bz_kb2

I could see the width of the device, the style of the keys, and/or the placement of the ports preventing some people from having an excellent thumb typing experience, but for the most part, I think the keyboard is well done. Thumb typing comfort is obviously affected if something is plugged into and sticking out of the USB port or headphone jack, though to what degree depends on how large and rigid the item is.

Backlighting and more space around each key are the only improvements I wouldn't mind seeing on the third-gen UMID keyboard. I suppose some might clamor for a right shift key as well. I don't use this key on any keyboard, so I never notice its absence. I don't consider it to be a serious omission on a thumboard either; StickyKeys is a fine workaround that I actually use on all handheld devices that support it.

Software

In addition to the standard applications and programs found on Windows XP Home computers, not to mention the countless ones you can install yourself, the UMID mbook BZ comes with Thepot Player UI (finger-friendly launcher UI shown below), ThinkFree Mobile Office, Cphone (for making phone calls with the BZ by connecting it to a cell phone via Bluetooth), and LogMeIn Ignition.

Umid_bz_pot

Performance

Although it was available in lower configurations, most users outside of Korea had the 1.33GHz UMID M1. Unfortunately for them, at the time of this writing the BZ is only available with the slower 1.2GHz Intel Atom Z515 processor. The RAM is still limited to 512MB too and the 32GB SSD in my unit is slower than the one in the M1 (this may not be the case with the 16GB BZs), so current M1 owners really need to be enticed by the hardware to consider upgrading (downgrading?).

Umid_bz_web

As you can see from the benchmarks below, performance isn't exactly what anyone would call impressive. However, for my purposes and usage, which is little more than running Firefox with a handful of tabs, the lower specs aren't an issue. Even when I run the BZ side-by-side with my M1, I don't notice any significant difference in lag or SSD access. I don't know why anyone would be running CPU-intensive applications on something like this, but I suppose the 0.13GHz difference could be felt in certain situations.

As on the UMID M1 and Viliv devices, the BZ awakens from standby in a matter of seconds and is so power-efficient that it can be left in standby (rather than hibernation) overnight with very little hit to the battery. It isn't an instant-on device, of course, but it's getting pretty close.

Benchmarks

Umid_bz_crystalmark 

Umid_bz_hdtune 

Umid_bz_diskmark

Battery Life

Powering the UMID BZ is a removable li-ion battery (7.4V, 2600mAh) advertised to provide up to 7 hours of runtime under the least power-consuming conditions.

Umid_bz_batt

In real-world usage with WiFi on and light to moderate web browsing, the BZ can surpass the 5-hour mark. By "light to moderate," I mean reading blogs, emailing, posting comments and forum entries, watching a few YouTube videos, downloading some content, and maybe occasionally streaming audio.

Umid_bz_batteat

With very heavy usage, WiFi/Bluetooth on, and screen brightness set to mid-level, Battery Eater (results above) indicates that the BZ can run for 3 hours and 40 minutes at 100% CPU usage. Pretty impressive for something this small, if you ask me.

Conclusion

If the UMID mbook BZ had been released with a faster processor and more RAM, it probably would've been an instant hit among MID/UMPC fans.

Umid_bz_final

It's built well, is stylish enough for most gadget connoisseurs, and fixes all of the hardware issues that plagued its predecessor, the M1. It has an optical mouse and mouse buttons, standard-size I/O ports, improved screen angle, strong display hinge, excellent touchscreen, good keyboard, fast resume from standby, great battery life, individually selectable wireless radios (which, as previously mentioned, the M1 didn't have), and a handy new Cap Sensor feature for quick access to various utilities. There's really very little not to like about the BZ . . . well, except for the CPU and RAM.

A boost in specs is all it would take for the BZ to give the upcoming Viliv N5 some serious competition.

:: Visit the UMID mbook BZ forum to  connect with other users, share tips, and troubleshoot ::

The UMID mbook BZ is available now for $549 from Dynamism.

Pocketables does not accept targeted advertising, phony guest posts, paid reviews, etc. Help us keep this way with support on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Jenn K. Lee

Jenn K. Lee is the founder of Pocketables. She loves gadgets the way most women love shoes and purses. The pieces in her tech wardrobe that go with everything are currently the Samsung Galaxy Note II, Sony Tablet P, and Nexus 7, but there are still a couple of vintage UMPCs/MIDs in the back of her closet.

More posts by Jenn | Subscribe to Jenn's posts

Avatar of Jenn K. Lee

23 thoughts on “Review: UMID mbook BZ

  • Great review as usual, Jenn! The BZ is, without a doubt, a big improvement over the M1, but UMID could have done just a bit more to make this device even better, and they may still be able to do it if they release higher-spec versions.

    But wait until you get your hands on the Viliv N5, because once you compare it to the BZ, it is game over. With higher specs, a slightly larger keyboard, and a more naturallly-positioned trackpoint, the N5 easily trumps the BZ.

    I just don’t get the 512MB RAM limitation in 2010, since many people will want to install Win 7 to take advantage of the extra touch support. Not to mention, most people complain when these devices are limited to only 1GB.

    Reply
  • Avatar of Comment

    How long did UMID take to release higher speced versions of the M1 from its initial release? I know that on a 1.33 GHz Vaio P overclocked to 1.7 GHz things still lag on Windows 7 (multiple browser tabs, heavy websites, general navigation of the OS and programs, etc).

    Reply
  • Jenn, is WiFi/BT still turned off after standby?

    Reply
  • Good review Jenn.

    Have you noticed any little hiccups in operation? I get the feeling that under heavy use the disk can block.
    Also noticed that the webcam isnt as fast (frame rate) as the m1 in skype. The cap bar isn’t very responsive too.

    There are a few other annoying things too. Ill be covering them in a live session today.

    http://www.umpcportal.com/2010/01/umid-bz-live-on-live-monday-2130-cet/

    Ive added this review to the product database.

    Reply
  • Avatar of modano

    i want it, but i cant justify it as i actually can wait for the viliv n5.

    Reply
  • Two questions:
    Are batteries for the M1 good in the BZ?

    What is that recession under the keyboard on the left side? Is it an LED indicator?

    Reply
  • “But wait until you get your hands on the Viliv N5, because once you compare it to the BZ, it is game over. With higher specs, a slightly larger keyboard, and a more naturallly-positioned trackpoint, the N5 easily trumps the BZ.”

    I think this is already a popular sentiment, even for those who haven’t seen the N5 in person yet.

    I wonder how many will actually wait for its release to decide between it and the BZ. I have a feeling many folks, particularly the gadget-obsessed, will just get the BZ now, even if only to keep themselves busy until the N5 is released.

    The specs are certainly lacking on the BZ, but like you said, I think it’s a great improvement over the M1.

    Reply
  • Hmm. The only little quirk I experienced happened after I wrote the review, and it was so incredibly minor that I didn’t think it was worth mentioning.

    Since you asked, though, it was just my desktop icons not being auto-arranged after resuming from standby. I had to re-check the “Auto Arrange” option. It was as though standby wiped out my desktop preference, which at the time was only that the icons be auto-arranged.

    I’m surprised that the SSD isn’t as fast as the ones in the M1. Fast SSD was one of the best features!

    Looking forward to hearing about your other annoyances. Recessed optical mouse and top-heavy design when held by the keyboard would be at the top of my list.

    Reply
  • No, the batteries aren’t interchangeable.

    Yes, it’s an LED indicator for the wireless radios.

    Reply
  • Mo more stylus? Nor stylus holder? Just curious, not that I want a stylus that much, especially now there is a mouse, but might be a deal break to hand-writing folks.

    Reply
  • A stylus might be included in the retail box, but I didn’t get one and there’s nowhere to store it on the device.

    I agree that it isn’t as necessary anymore because of the mouse, but including a stylus slot/silo wouldn’t have hurt. It sure looks like there’s more than enough room for one.

    Reply
  • I could never get a good enough response from the touchscreen to use it for notes. Granted, I didn’t load XP Tablet edition, I just used the drivers for the touchscreen that were given by UMID. I did set it up for 25 point calibration, but I just wasn’t impressed with the screen as a writing device.

    Has anyone else had better results with the UMID?

    Bear in mind, I’ve been playing around on the Mintpad, and an Irex Iliad, both with wonderful touchscreens, so maybe other devices have jaded my opinion.

    Reply
  • Avatar of Yanovski

    Hi

    Can the device power up a portable USB HDD ?

    Regards

    Reply
  • Yes, you can attach a USB hard drive with no problem. I have connected a Western Digital Passport drive (powered by the BZ) and moved files between it and the UMID just fine.

    Reply
  • Jenn, which would you recommend if you’d have to choose: umid m1, umid bz or kohjinsha pa? Luckily I can also wait for N5 to appear for you to review so I get review on that aswell. That 1GB ram might be just the thing that matters.

    Reply
  • What do you want to use it for? They all have their strengths and weaknesses, depending on the usage scenario.

    Reply
  • Avatar of ossi

    It would be mostly entertainment. Surfing web,listening to music, watching movies, playing some flash games and emulators and other old games and occasionally I could hook it to tv. I might also do some light office work and notetaking for school. I would also hook it to my stereos for spotify.

    I guess they all have quite similar battery-life but other things that I’d like to have are: somewhat loud speaker, possibly 3.5mm audio-out, SSD, touchscreen, small enough to be pocketable, higher resolution than 800×480 and keyboard. On the keyboard part I think would like it to open as much as possible if it is a clamshell. I think most of those are similar in all the devices so I find it really hard to figure out what I would like the most. If you have recommendations for any other devices I would be happy to hear. If they are too similar I think I will just buy the cheapest.

    Reply
  • Yes, they’re all very similar, especially for your requirements. If you want something now, I’d go with the UMID BZ unless you need a convertible screen (Kohjinsha PA) or the absolute smallest device (M1). Otherwise I’d wait to find out more about the Viliv N5.

    The other devices are capable of doing what you want, but the extra RAM and Win7 in the N5 will make a difference in performance.

    Reply
  • Avatar of ossi

    Thanks Jenn. I have to save money for it anyway so I won’t be buying one yet. I guess waiting for N5 is a good idea then.

    Reply
  • Avatar of Eddie Lau

    I really agree that UMID BZ is much better than M1. However, I don’t know the reason why the company or factory would not change 512MB to 1 GB ram. It is hard to operate some kinds of software. As a smart customer, we are looking for best improvement on the UMPC market.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *