AccessoriesAndroid

Living with the Tellstick Net, three months in

tellstick net1 - for some reason we don't have an alt tag here

A little over three months ago, I reviewed the TellStick Net home automation bridge. The tiny device plugs into your router and creates a bridge between a whole range of (third party) home automation equipment and the internet, and through that, your Android, iOS, or Windows Phone device, any desktop OS, or really just any browser. I’ve used the system constantly since I first got it, so I thought I would write a follow up with my long term experiences.

Home automation still has a very peculiar position in people’s minds, as something you see in science fiction movies or in rich people’s houses on TV. That’s very far from the truth, as in reality, many people have vacuum cleaners more expensive than the total cost of automating your house. Here in expensive old Norway, the Europe-only TellStick Net runs you about $140 on a good day, with equipment for it starting at $10-15 and going up to about $50 for the most common devices you would connect to something like that. I bought a few various plug adapters and whatnot, but as I like in a tiny student apartment, I’ve gradually abandoned things like desk lights and kitchen appliances and now get the absolute most use out of my dimmable ceiling light and two temperature sensors.

When I first got everything set up, I had a lot of fun just playing with everything, making it controllable with voice commands from my phone, and so on. Nothing quite says “welcome to the future” like telling your phone “lights off” and have it happen. That particular example is still so much fun that I used it to point out the difference between Siri and a custom voice control system on Android:

In daily use though, I don’t ever control anything with voice commands. For the most part, commands to control my lights or fetch temperature information are part of automatic scenarios in Tasker on Android, which is a whole different way of doing things. Instead of me using my phone to turn off the lights because I’m leaving the house, the actual event of me leaving the house makes my phone turn off the lights. It sounds like magic, but is just a simple combination of the events “I lost my WiFi connection to network X” with “send this command to the TellStick Net” from my phone’s perspective. Similarly, coming home is tied to turning on the lights. Those are just part of what the phone does when leaving or coming home though, as it also adjusts its own screen brightness, checks for items in todo lists, and other TellStick-unrelated things. What I did end up doing that is TellStick related is to have the outside temperature automatically show up in a widget on the lock screen when I leave the house, and have the phone read the inside temperature out loud when I come home.

I also have other scenarios where the home automation aspect is just part of a process, not a conscious action. Plugging in my phone at night activates sleep mode, which does a whole bunch of things, most noticeably dim the screen light, activate silent mode, turn off my PC, and turn off my lights. Again it’s all about scenarios, not individual actions. These are things people still do manually, while for me it’s simply become the state that my apartment goes into when I plug in my phone. It still amuses me to read about iOS’ “Do Not Disturb” mode, which compared to my phone’s sleep mode makes me wonder if it’s fair to Android to call iPhones “smartphones.” I also have variations of this sleep mode, namely nap mode, which lets me hit a single button to silence my phone, turn off my PC monitors (not turn off the PC), and turn off the lights in one go. On top of that I have other scenarios, as well as a quick access control panel (also made in Tasker) that allows me to access manual controls and temperature readings from both the home screen and lock screen.

The point I’m trying to make is that home automation is not about standing in the middle of your living room and screaming “lights off,” to use the scene from the 9th season of Two and a Half Men as an example. I can do that, but that’s not really home automation, now is it? You’re just switching out the act of flipping a switch with the act of saying “lights off”. Automatic transmissions switch gears for you, they don’t require you to scream “switch gears now!!!!” to the bloody thing. Home automation is all about making your home intelligent, not just make it a voice activated, but still just as stupid, home.

Once you do have scenarios set up, it quickly becomes just as natural as anything else, but that doesn’t mean you don’t notice a difference. I particularly like my sleep mode, as it allows me to go to bed without essentially having to tuck in my apartment first. If I wake up in the middle of the night, I can flip on all the lights I need from the lock screen of my phone sitting next to me, without the need for some tiny bedside lamp that lights up an area just large enough for you to miss the first toe-killing piece of furniture but hit the second.

As for issues with the TellStick, I have had a couple, but nothing major. The Telldus Live! service that is used for the internet communication part of everything has been down a few times from what I’ve seen on Twitter, but I always seem to either be on an unaffected server or miss the outage for other reasons. At one point the power went out, and when it came back on, the internet was still out for half an hour, leaving me without a connection to my lights. Still, it was a matter of flipping a switch to turn them on manually, and hardly Armageddon. My favorite TellStick moment of the last three months was however when I came home from the store, and found the building’s janitor and an electrician inside trying to turn the lights back on after they had cut the power for a routine (planned) building-wide check of the electrical system.

Some would say that home automation is for lazy people. It’s not. If anything, lack of home automation is for people who like to do extra work for no reason. We have tons of appliances that at some point in history has become a standard part of any home, simply because running around with a broom when you can buy a vacuum cleaner that does the job better serves no purpose. We use lamps with lightbulbs, because they’re easier and superior to candle lights or oil lamps. Avoiding unnecessary work is not laziness, it’s logic. Home automation is just that: Avoiding unnecessary work. We live by predictable patterns, and if it’s predictable, you can automate it. Cost was an issue when home automation was about major investments while building a new house, but it isn’t anymore. So, if you live somewhere you can use a TellStick or something similar, I really suggest you seriously consider home automation as your next “appliance.”

Pocketables does not accept targeted advertising, phony guest posts, paid reviews, etc. Help us keep this way with support on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Andreas Ødegård

Andreas Ødegård is more interested in aftermarket (and user created) software and hardware than chasing the latest gadgets. His day job as a teacher keeps him interested in education tech and takes up most of his time.

Avatar of Andreas Ødegård

12 thoughts on “Living with the Tellstick Net, three months in

  • Your first article made me buy one of this great devices and since then I have nearly every light in my apartment controlled by it. The best thing was integrating this with other things in Tasker. Like having the light go on when the sun goes down or if I watch a movie on my media center was just great. Keep those tutorials coming. They are a great source of inspiration for my own projects.

    Reply
    • Avatar of Andreas Ødegård

      Glad to see you got one and like it! Tasker integration is really what makes this shine, at least if you don’t have a computer on 24/7, and even then there are some things you can only do from a device you have with you

      Reply
  • Avatar of oviano

    Interesting articles.

    I’m looking to invest in the tellstick system to provide a means to remotely reboot a couple of Slingboxes if they ever need it.

    Is the system reliable though? For example, I may be away from the Slingbox location for several months – will the system carry on working? Have you ever had to do anything to the socket receivers to ‘wake them up’ (eg unplug, replug)?

    Currently my Slingboxes are on automated digital timers which has proved very reliable. While tellstick would give me better control, I’m concerned they might introduce their own element if unreliability.

    Reply
    • Avatar of Andreas Ødegård

      Occasionally the servers are down, which means commands won’t go through. This won’t turn off the power to connected devices, nor does it require any action on your end once the servers are back up, it just means you’ll be unable to control something for a little while. Other than that, I’ve never had to un/replug anything, or otherwise fix anything. Power, or internetoutages are also non-issues, as the thing will just spring back to life on its own

      Reply
  • Avatar of Claes Malmström

    Hi Andreas
    I purchased a TellStick Net to control the heating in our cottage but I have not found any good application that can read my thermometer AND depending on the value control the radiators. I would like the Tellstick to control the radiators when we are not in the cottage having a temp at about 8-10C and then when we know that we will go up there on the weekend I would just put it on manual and have the radiators termostat take over the control setting it to 21C.
    Have you found anything that could do this ?

    Reply
    • Avatar of Andreas Ødegård

      If Tellstick can control the radiator and read the thermometer, Tasker can combine the two to do what you want.

      Reply
  • Avatar of Claes Malmström

    Hi Andreas and thanks for your fast respons
    Correct me if I´m wrong but to run Tasker I need an Android unit. Is there a windows version of Tasker ?
    Or even better, is there an iOS version on it´s way ?

    Reply
    • Avatar of Andreas Ødegård

      Yes Tasker is Android only. Eventghost for Windows might be able to do what you want, but I honestly don’t know. Nothing for iOS, nor will there ever be, because iOS is way too locked down for something like Tasker. My advice, if you’re serious about home automation, is to get an Android phone. iPhones are neat- I have an iPad myself- but for things like this you might as well have two cans with a string between them- that’s about as useful. Just take alook at what someone did with Tasker: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjTj0ymhbBw

      Reply
  • With the previous version of Tellstick I could switch on an additional heater in the cottage according to the weather forcast a day or two or three before going there and then hope for the best. It is now a great advantage that the new Tellstick can handle sensors and remotely with an app like Telldus Live in a smartphone let me monitor the temperature and the humidity in and around my cottage. I have found the Tellstick system reliable, but as I am using a reversible A/C – heatpump it would be nice to know that it actually starts when I remotely miles away switch it on with the app, and not only by waiting to see if the temperature goes up. It would be good if the Tellstick could handle a sensor in the form of a coil around the live wire feeding electricity the the heater, and show how much electricity the heater is using. Best Regards

    Reply
  • My Tellstick was at first controlling switches made by GE or GEO, but when I realised that each switch was consuming 6 or 7 watt each even without anything connected to them I changed to Nexa switches. They consume less than my energy meter can register, and according to the spec only 0.25 watt each.

    Reply
  • Avatar of Bjørn

    Hi Andreas!

    Interesting reading, and I would like to try some of it out myself.

    I know you recommend an Android phone with Tasker, but I would also like to achieve some of the same things with other phones and devices, including iPhone/WinPhone.
    I’ve been trying out EventGhost, which seems pretty neat for triggering events that you can monitor from a computer. Thus I tried to set up a periodic ping against the local IP of my phone to determin whether it’s “home” or not. It seemed promising, however it turns out that after it has been idle for just a bit (screen turned off) it stops responding to ping, as if the network chip has gone into sleep mode or something. The same goes for my iPad.

    How does your set-up actually detect that your phone is no longer home?

    Best regards,
    -Bjørn

    Reply
  • Great article! My system is on its way in the mail as we speak. Can’t wait :)

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *